Home Blogs Digital contact tracing: Why Americans have a problem with it

Digital contact tracing: Why Americans have a problem with it

Hit by severe resource crunch — both financial and manpower — health authorities in the US are struggling with manual contact tracing to combat the virus. Digital contact tracing could have helped manage this unprecedented crisis. But the lack of a clear national strategy and intent to build public trust over personal data sharing have combined to fail this technology from being an effective tool in COVID mitigation.

Digital contact tracing fail in US
This map by The Guardian shows the number of confirmed COVID-19 deaths per 100,000 Americans. There are currently over 169,000 COVID-related deaths confirmed in the US. With an estimated population of 322 million, that equals to about 52 deaths 100,000 Americans.

On August 12, the United States reported the highest number of COVID-19 related deaths (1,499) since mid-May, taking the total toll to over 169,000 by the weekend. On the same day, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Robert Redfield said that years of underinvestment in public health infrastructure left the United States “unprepared” for the “greatest public health crisis that hit this nation” in a century. 

With no treatment and vaccine in place, there is only one tried and tested tool that has proved effective for many other countries – contact tracing – but that doesn’t seem to be working for America. The reasons are many – lack of a clear national strategy and funding being the issues that the Trump administration has faced criticism for. However, there is another important reason for its apparent failure –  lack of public trust. The fact that the pandemic has been highly politicized by now has only worsened the situation.

ALSO READ: Finding the middle ground in safety vs data privacy debate

The success of contact tracing as a tool is squarely dependent on people’s trust and cooperation. As health offices across the country are understaffed and struggling to reach out to people for manual contact tracing, the politically charged environment is making the process challenging. Recent protests and unrest over systemic racism in the country, or the rhetoric about immigration, may also make certain communities hesitant in disclosing personal information.

In this background, what could have worked well was digital contact tracing, which has proved effective in containing the virus in many countries.

What is digital contact tracing and how does it work?

In the aftermath of the COVID-19 outbreak, almost every country rushed to introduce contact tracing smartphone apps that could track users’ movements through GPS, location data and Bluetooth technology. Once a person tests positive, authorities can use the location of his/her mobile phone to track the places he/she had visited in the recent past. Based on that information, the officials trace the individuals who have come in contact with the infected person. Those people are further tested and, if required, quarantined.

Bluetooth apps enable immediate mobile alerts to people who could run into a COVID-positive person or an area with multiple cases. The technology eventually leads to identification of hotspots and clusters.

ALSO READ: How geospatial data and technologies can help in disease prevention and control

Advantages and disadvantages

Digital contract tracing relieves several challenges associated with traditional manual investigation and contact tracing. The technology augments the capacity of the health authorities and contact tracing workforce by making the process faster and often without physical intervention – thus ensuring safety of the health workers. This leads to rapid isolation of contacts to interrupt the chain of transmission.

However, while these apps have been successfully implemented in several countries, there are several critical gaps. According to the CDC, there are currently very limited data on the performance of these apps, particularly the sensitivity of these methods, as it pertains to identifying true close contacts. “Many tools are not yet widely available, and there remain critical gaps that could pose challenges to their implementation. There are two major technologies that are under discussion in the United States – Bluetooth and GPS. There are currently little published empirical data showing the capabilities of either technology,” the CDC says.

Further, since this requires people to have access to smartphones, knowledge of how to install apps, and literacy to navigate app menus, it may not be effective until a “critical mass of users” in a community are using these apps. For digital contract tracing to be fool-proof, individuals are required to keep their smartphones on them at all times with the apps enabled. It is also dependent on the users that they share the appropriate information with health authorities.

ALSO READ: Will COVID-19 change how our cities are designed in the future?

Data privacy – the big debate

However, the biggest debate that has come out of digital contract tracing apps has been around data privacy concerns, since much of this data is people’s personal data, and hence sensitive in nature. There are also concerns that hacking and other unauthorized access or use of data may compromise data security and confidentiality.

While traditional authoritarian governments in China and Singapore used the technology successfully, in several countries, they faced roadblocks. For instance, India made its official contact racing app mandatory, but then switched to “advisable”, as concerns mounted over data security.

In the case of Germany, which had initially launched an app developed under the Pan-European Privacy-Preserving Proximity Tracing initiative, the government had to roll it back midway amid concerns over state surveillance and go for an alternative which had a decentralized data storing model. The most successful has been the South Korean model which deployed one of the most intrusive contact tracing technology and extensive testing to keep the count low.

Trust deficit in the US

The American citizens’ support for the administration is currently at an all-time low. Their trust in tech companies hasn’t been too high either in recent times. From Snowden to Cambridge Analytica, a string of scandals over data privacy breaches have left the common American suspicious about data sharing.

Making matters worse is the absence of any cohesive national strategy for deploying such apps, unlike in other parts of the world – from China to Singapore to India to even Europe. This left the states to pretty much do whatever they pleased, with no message to the public underlining its importance.

Undoubtedly, a lot of work is required around the data privacy issue, and more consultation is needed on the ethical and legal issues related to electronic tracking, before digital contract tracing becomes a norm. However, there has been almost next to nothing effort so far from the authorities in US to build public trust in the ability and intention to preserve the privacy of individuals.

Digital contract tracing wouldn’t have saved US from the virus, but it could have surely given it a fighting chance.

ALSO READ: The burning Arctic, pandemics and the need for a green recovery

Anusuya Datta
A writer based out of Canada, Anusuya is the Editor (Technology & Innovation) focused on developments in North America. Earlier she has worked with Geospatial World as the Executive Editor. A published author on several international platforms, she has worked with some of the finest brands in Indian media. A writer by choice, an editor by profession, and a technology commentator by chance, Anusuya is passionate about news and numbers, but it is the intersection of technology and sustainability and humanitarian issues that excites her most.